scroll down

The Best Memory Foam Mattress Topper Reviews

It’s easy to undervalue just how greatly a memory foam mattress topper can improve your sleep if you’ve never tried one.

Mattress toppers are incredible because of how soft they are, how they effectively isolate motion across their surface, and how much cushion they provide. The quality of your sleep determines how the next day goes, so if you’re looking to massively improve your resting periods, investing in a mattress topper should be considered.

The Best Memory Foam Mattress Toppers Reviewed

In this article, we will look at the 5 best memory foam mattress toppers you can buy. These mattress toppers are popular for their comfort, performance, durability, and ease of maintenance.

There is also a buyer’s guide at the end of the review section to help you with your purchasing decision.

Our Top Pick

Our Top Pick

DreamFoam Gel Swirl

Perfect in Every Way

The DreamFoam Gel Swirl is a 2-inch memory foam mattress topper that is one of the highest rated of its kind on Amazon. This topper offers great comfort and cushioning without causing heating issues. It also comes at an incredible price.

The combination of its performance and price point make the DreaFoam Gel Swirl perhaps the best choice in mattress toppers. Don’t believe us? Just read the 4,500+ Amazon reviews!

Great Alternative

Great Alternative

Red Nomad 2-inch Gel Infused

As Good as Our Top Pick

The Red Nomad 2-inch Gel infused mattress topper takes a lot from its older sister, only utilizing gel-infused memory foam for added comfort and motion isolation. This mattress topper offers just about everything the DreamFoam does.

If you can’t find the DreamFoam or just want to be a bit different, the Red Nomad 2-inch Gel infused mattress topper is an excellent alternative for a few extra bucks.

DreamFoam Gel Swirl

DreamFoam

The 2-inch DreamFoam Gel Swirl mattress topper is one of the highest (if not the highest) rated mattress toppers on Amazon. This topper is well known for being incredibly soft and has the ability to instantly adjust to the shape of the individual’s body.

Yet despite being incredibly soft and cushioning, this mattress topper is not squishy at all. It is also excellent at isolated vibrations, making it ideal for couples. You will no longer have to worry about your significant other disturbing you as they twist and turn in the middle of the night.

The DreamFoam Gel Swirl is great in many other ways as well. It is one of the few memory foam mattress toppers that do not overheat the individual(s) lying on the best. What makes this mattress truly stand out though is despite its near-perfect performance and offering, it is one of the cheapest high-quality mattress toppers you can buy.

For these reasons combined, the DreamFoam is our top pick.

Pros

  • Great value
  • Incredibly soft and comfortable
  • Isolates vibration and movement

Cons

  • None

Lucid 3-inch Memory Foam

Lucid

Another contender for the best mattress topper you can buy is the Lucid 3-inch memory foam. Though not very dense, the Lucid mattress topper is gel infused and has excellent ventilation.

Its low density does not mean it is not durable; this mattress topper is quite formidable, and does not show permanent imprints in it even after a long night’s sleep. Many memory foam mattress toppers have the problem of overheating.

However, due to the Lucid’s low density, it is incredibly airy, allowing for enhanced airflow for a comfortable and peaceful sleep. The gel infused memory foam will also ensure that you do not feel too cold during winters. It is fantastic at regulating temperature.

On top of all this, the Lucid 3-inch memory foam is also priced at a great value. It does have a downside due to its airiness though: it takes a little while longer to off-gas than other mattress toppers. However, that additional wait is worth it.

Pros

  • High quality build and performance
  • Provides excellent ventilation
  • Incredibly comfortable

Cons

  • Off-gassing can take more time than usual

Best Price 4-inch

BestPrice

The Best Price 4-inch mattress topper is incredibly durable and offers a great warranty. Coming at 5 years warranty period, this heavy but soft and comfortable mattress topper is specifically designed to live long and prosper. It features an active suspension which greatly isolates motion, making it ideal for couples.

The mattress is made from a double layer construction, which is what gives its thickness. The first layer is made of density foam, and it is 2.5 inches in width. The remaining bit is made from regular memory foam.

As a result this isn’t a true memory foam mattress topper, but it’s not intended to be.  The mattress does weigh in a little heavy at 29 pounds, but that makes sense due to its thickness.

Pros

  • Double layer construction gives great durability
  • Responsive and active suspension
  • 5 years warranty is more than most memory foam mattress toppers
  • Very comfortable

Cons

  • Has quality control issues
  • Tends to deform after prolonged use

Red Nomad 2-inch Gel Infused

RedNomad

If you want an alternative to the DreaFoam, the Red Nomad 2-inch mattress topper is a great choice. In fact, it is hardly distinguishable in features and performance from our top pick, the DreamFoam.

The density of the mattress is also the same, around 2.5 pounds per cubic foot. The Red Nomad 2-inch takes a lot from the ever popular Red Nomad regular mattress topper. The main difference is that this one is gel-infused.

It is incredibly soft and comfortable. According to the company itself, the mattress has “true support” features that alleviate muscle aches and great help reduce pressure points. As with most high quality mattress toppers, this one is incredibly and isolating motion and vibration, making it excellent for a good night’s sleep with a fidgety partner.

Pros

  • Incredibly soft and comfortable
  • Great motion isolation
  • Great ventilation

Cons

  • A tad more expensive than the DreamFoam, which makes it a second favorite

Malouf Isolus 2.5 Gel Topper

Isolus

The Malouf Isolus 2.5 Gel mattress topper is wonderful if you want a very plush, soft, and cushioned surface. This is one of the softest mattress toppers out there, making you feel like you’re lying on a cloud.

The Isolus has been designed in such a way that when you lie on it, you fell like you’re sinking into the bed. This by no means is a bad thing with this product – the mattress does not restrict your movements or make you feel like you’re trapped. In fact, it cradles you wonderfully.

However, this can play as a double-edged sword. Because there is so much contact between the mattress and your body, it can make you sweat and heat up. This is a problem in warmer homes and hotter climates. For people living in cooler conditions or have the heating system turned low, this is actually a plus.

The cushiony comfort will give you a great night’s sleep as long as your room is not too warm. The other major downside to this mattress is its price. This is a premium-priced product which will turn away many users. You will definitely want to invest the additional money though if you’re looking for ultimate cushion comfort.

Pros

  • Unmatched cushioning
  • Great motion isolation
  • Unparalleled comfort

Cons

  • Tends to overheat the body
  • Expensive

Buyer’s Guide

    Memory foam has what is known as density value. This is the amount of foam contained in a cubic feet, and is usually measured in pounds per cubic foot.

    A higher density mattress topper may or may not be firmer – there isn’t always a direct correlation. Where there is a link though is that higher density tends to provide more durability. Denser mattress toppers will break down a less over time.

    However, mattress toppers with high density ratings will also have inferior ventilation and could make you feel hot. Ideally, you want to choose a density level of 4pcf or 5pcf. Heavier individuals will want to invest in one that is denser.

    The size of the mattress topper should match the size of your bed, obviously. The size also determines the price of the mattress. All the products listed in this article offer the most common sizes. These are Full, Califirnoa King, Twin, Twin XL, Queen, and King.

    The thickness of the mattress topper affects how deep the mattress can compress when you sleep on it. The most important factor in deciding what thickness is right for is by determining the position you sleep in. Back and slide sleepers will want 2.5 inch or greater mattress toppers as the spine and/or arms tend to compress the mattress a lot more.

    On the other hand, if you sleep on your stomach, you will do just fine with a 2-inch mattress, as the tummy doesn’t compress the mattress topper all that much.

    Though density and quality of the mattress topper plays the greatest role in its durability and life, how much you care and maintain it also matters. You should not keep heavy items on mattress toppers, and only use it for sleep.

    Additionally, a mattress topper will greatly wear and tear if jumped on, as they are not designed to withstand such concentrated pressure.

    You will want to wash your mattress topper regularly as well. It is highly recommended that you use a cover, as the porous nature of mattress toppers means stains are absorbed easily. Stains and fluids can also greatly speed up the breakdown process of the mattress topper.

    What’s the difference between a topper and a pad?

    If you’re asking this question, you’re not the only one. Mattress toppers and pads are used in a similar way, but they are quite different in function. Mattress toppers are usually thicker as provide extra cushioning.

    Pads are a lot like a cover that provides a small amount of cushioning as well as warmth. Memory foam mattress toppers on the other hand are an additional layer of cushion that provide you with the right amount of support and ease stress on your body.

    Why buy a mattress topper?

    If your sleep is uncomfortable or you tend to have aches and pains after you wake up, a mattress topper could greatly help. They are sensitive to the contours of your body, which means they adjust in a way to ensure there is minimal pressure points on your body as you sleep.

    Additionally, a mattress topper is great at isolating motion. If you have a sleeping partner who twists and turns a lot at night, you’ll be surprised as how little of that you’ll notice while on a mattress topper.

    What’s the best way to off-gas a mattress topper?

    When you initially unwrap a mattress topper, it will release gas. Whether the materials are toxic or not is still under research and up for debate. Because of the airiness of the memory foam, the gases are trapped inside the pores.

    You need to let the mattress rest for a while in order to let the gases escape completely. This can take anywhere between a few hours to a couple of days, varying from product to product.

    Do I need a cover for my mattress topper?

    Some mattress toppers will arrive with a cover. Others won’t. While they are not mandatory, it’s recommended to have a cover on your memory foam topper so it remains clean. Cleaning a mattress topper is easy, but they also stain quite easily because of how porous they are.

    Leave your Comment

    Your email address will not be published.